💱Culture & Status

Economist · The scholar of scarcity — from Adam Smith's pin factory to the central-bank decision room, still asked to predict what no model fully captures.

Few professions have swung between contempt and command so completely. Aristotle ranked money-making among the lowest human activities; medieval theology treated lending at interest as sin; Carlyle sneered at "the dismal science." Yet by the mid twentieth century economists were writing national budgets, and today fourteen words from a central banker — most famously Mario Draghi's "whatever it takes" in July 2012 — can move trillions in asset prices.

The culture that grew around the profession reflects that double reputation. Economists are simultaneously the butt of a whole genre of jokes about unworldly forecasters — and the only academics whose annual mountain-resort symposium is broadcast live on financial television. Both facts are telling, and both are earned.

Social standing through history

How much status the profession carried in each era, on a 0–100 scale.

2038558468
Antiquity & Middle AgesMercantile era (1500–1776)Classical era (1776–1890)The technocratic ascent (1936–2008)Post-crisis present (2008– )
Antiquity & Middle Ages

Thinking systematically about money carried a moral taint: Aristotle condemned chrematistics, and the medieval church condemned usury outright. Estate stewards were respected servants, but no one held status as an economic thinker; the subject survived inside philosophy, law and theology.

Mercantile era (1500–1776)

Merchants and pamphleteers advising crowns on trade and coinage gained real if precarious influence — Jean-Baptiste Colbert ran France's economy for Louis XIV, and William Petty was knighted — but they were courtiers and projectors, not members of a recognized learned profession.

Classical era (1776–1890)

Political economists became genuine public intellectuals: Smith's book was quoted in Parliament within his lifetime, Ricardo bought a seat in it, and Mill's Principles educated a governing class. Still a gentleman's pursuit — there were chairs but almost no careers.

The technocratic ascent (1936–2008)

Depression, war and Keynes made economists indispensable to government. They designed Bretton Woods, staffed treasuries and central banks, won a Nobel from 1969, and by the 1990s chaired the institutions — Fed, IMF, ECB — that steered the world economy. Peak prestige, and peak deference.

Post-crisis present (2008– )

The 2008 crisis, which almost no mainstream forecast foresaw, dented public trust — the Queen's pointed question at the LSE became the era's emblem — and populist politics openly discounts expert economic advice. The profession remains powerful, better paid than ever, and noticeably more humble in its claims.

In film, books and art

Film2015

The Big Short

Adam McKay, from Michael Lewis's book

The Oscar-winning comedy-drama follows the handful of analysts and fund managers who read the mortgage data everyone else ignored and bet against the US housing market before 2008 — celebrity cameos explain collateralized debt obligations directly to camera, making dry financial economics a mass-audience subject.

Book2005

Freakonomics

Steven D. Levitt & Stephen J. Dubner

A University of Chicago economist and a journalist applied the field's tools to sumo cheating, baby names and drug-gang finances, selling millions of copies worldwide. The book recast the economist in popular culture from forecaster of GDP to all-purpose detective of hidden incentives, and launched a durable podcast franchise.

Film2001

A Beautiful Mind

Ron Howard, from Sylvia Nasar's biography

The four-Oscar biopic of John Nash dramatizes the Princeton mathematician whose 1950 equilibrium concept became the foundation of modern game theory — and of the 1994 economics Nobel he shared — while following his decades-long struggle with schizophrenia, giving economic theory its most famous cinematic moment.

Book2013

Capital in the Twenty-First Century

Thomas Piketty

The Paris School of Economics professor's 700-page history of wealth concentration, built on two centuries of tax records, became an improbable global bestseller with some 2.5 million copies sold, put r > g on protest placards, and made a working economist a household name across a dozen countries.

Film2018

Default (국가부도의 날)

Choi Kook-hee

South Korea's hit drama about the 1997 Asian financial crisis follows a Bank of Korea monetary-policy team head, played by Kim Hye-soo, who sees national bankruptcy coming and fights her own government's secrecy as the IMF negotiations close in — a rare film whose hero is a working central-bank economist.

Documentary2010

Inside Job

Charles Ferguson

The Academy Award-winning documentary on the 2008 crisis is also the sharpest on-screen indictment of the profession itself: on-camera interviews expose prominent academic economists paid handsomely for reports and testimony favorable to the financial industry, and the film is credited with pushing US universities toward conflict-of-interest disclosure rules.

Proverbs and idioms

In the long run we are all dead.

John Maynard Keynes, A Tract on Monetary Reform (1923)Keynes's rebuke to colleagues who promised markets would fix themselves eventually: advice that only works in the long run is useless to people suffering now. Still quoted whenever economists debate austerity against stimulus.

There is no such thing as a free lunch.

American saying, popularized by Milton Friedman as a 1975 book titleEvery choice costs the best alternative forgone — opportunity cost, the discipline's most fundamental idea, folded into a phrase borrowed from saloons that offered "free" food to anyone buying drinks.

Give me a one-handed economist!

Attributed to US President Harry S. TrumanTruman's exasperation at advisers who answered every question with "on the one hand… on the other hand." The profession's honest habit of stating both sides, seen from the decision-maker's chair, looks like an inability to commit.

It's the economy, stupid.

James Carville, Clinton campaign war room, 1992A strategist's wall-sign reminder that elections turn on economic conditions before anything else — now shorthand, worldwide, for the political primacy of growth, jobs and prices over every other issue.

Rites, symbols and dress

The job market

Almost the entire global market for new PhD economists clears through one coordinated annual ritual: candidates distill their dissertation into a single "job market paper," interview at the American Economic Association's January meetings or the European winter equivalent, then fly out for day-long seminar auditions. Where a career starts is largely settled in those few weeks — a centralized rite no other social science shares.

Jackson Hole

Every August since 1982, the Kansas City Fed has convened central bankers and academics at Jackson Lake Lodge in Wyoming — a venue chosen, by the organizers' own account, partly because the fly-fishing might tempt Fed chairman Paul Volcker to attend. It worked, and the symposium became the profession's most-watched pulpit: markets now parse every word of the chair's Jackson Hole speech in real time.

The seminar interruption

Economics seminars are famously combative: audiences interrupt from the first slide, and surviving the barrage is treated as initiation. The folklore became data in 2019, when a study presented to the American Economic Association found economists in seminars were interrupted substantially more often than scholars in comparable fields — and that women presenters drew disproportionately more of the interruptions, forcing an ongoing reckoning with the culture.

The jokes and the rituals describe the same tension: a profession asked to speak with scientific authority about a system that keeps surprising it. The two-handed hedging Truman mocked and the fan charts central banks publish are the same instinct in different dress — honesty about uncertainty, in a job where someone must decide anyway.

That tension is precisely why filmmakers keep returning to the figure of the economist who saw it coming: the fantasy, and occasionally the fact, of someone who read the data honestly while everyone else looked away.

Keep exploring

More in Business & Finance