Origins

Dweck’s early work on learned helplessness and later “theories of intelligence” grew from 1970s motivation research. The public name “growth mindset” arrives with the 2006 book and a vast school-consulting afterlife.

The timeline below follows dated arguments and institutions, not a national myth of genius and not a group ranking.

Origin

1970s–2006 · United States — Dweck’s early work on learned helplessness and later “theories of intelligence” grew from 1970s motivation research. The public name “growth mindset” arrives with the 2006 book and a vast school-consulting afterlife.

Timeline

1. 1970sHelplessness in children

   Dweck studies why some children quit after failure — a motivation problem, not an IQ one.

2. 1988Goals and theories

   Elliott and Dweck and related papers: learning versus performance goals sit with implicit theories.

3. 1998Mueller & Dweck praise

   Intelligence praise versus effort praise becomes the famous classroom experiment.

4. 2006Mindset published

   The trade book that globalised the vocabulary.

5. 2007Blackwell, Trzesniewski, Dweck

   A junior-high intervention links incremental theory to maths grades in their sample.

6. 2010sNational rollouts

   US, UK and other systems buy programmes and posters at scale.

7. 2018Sisk et al. meta-analyses

   Psychological Science: small average effects; some larger in at-risk groups.

8. 2018–19Li & Bates replications

   Key praise findings fail to replicate in their reports — a public crack in the brand.

9. 2019Yeager et al. National Study

   A large US study finds small average effects, larger for lower-achieving students under supportive climates.

10. 2020sModesty era

    Even advocates now talk about “supportive context” rather than a sticker that raises IQ.

Eras

• Helplessness lab — Why kids quit — A motivation research programme, not yet a school product.
• Praise experiments — Words after success — 1998 makes adult language a treatment.
• Trade-book boom — Mindset as brand — Consultants outrun the error bars.
• Meta-analytic cooling — 2018 — Sisk sizes the average effect as small.
• Contextual turn — Climate plus belief — Yeager and others: the message needs a school that actually allows challenge.

Shifts

• From lab praise to national posters 1998–2015 — A delicate experiment became a wall display.
• From large story to small d 2018 — Meta-analysis pulled the public claim back toward modest effects.
• From solo belief to climate 2019– — Interventions that ignore tracking, load and feedback quality underperform.

Growth mindset: keep the dates visible. Names of talents are younger than the work they try to capture.

OriginsScienceSignsDevelopPracticeExemplarsMyths In this language region